2.2 American Revolution and the Constitution
American Revolution and the Constitution
2020-04-27 15:32 :13
#review
- 1776 - opened the door of modern age for mankind
Reasons
Lack of Affection for Britain
- Many people were either punished, sent to America or escaped, forced to migrate thus there was weak bonding w/ Br
- No help in dev of America, during fight with Native Indians
Role of Matured State of Americans
- Developed politico-administratively ex legislature and socio-culturally
- Typical American culture dev due to intermingling of various other cultures
- Economic progress led by plantation industry was high
- American merchants were active in trade, industries were also advanced
- Intellectual awakening of Americans - Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, Patrick Henry
Role of Change in Character of Britain
- British rule become symbolic - only upper level of adm was run by B,
- America was not source of economic gain, reign only ceremonial, French presence in Canada was the main reason why Br troops were in America.
- 7 years war led to Br defeat to pay for it imposed taxes
- Sugar Act 1764, Currency Act 1764, Stamp Act 1765 and Quartering act 1765 imposed new taxes
- Townshend act 1767,
- James Ottis gave the slogan of 'No Taxation without representation'
Immediate Circumstances
- After end of 7 year war mutual animosity of French among minds of British and Americans which bonded them together was no more
- No representation in British parliament but taxes were imposed
Tea Policy of Lord North
- British PM the tea acquired from the trade of China was exported to America with heavy taxes
- American traders lost on profit
- Samuel Adams along w/ supporters entered the Boston port, threw Tea bags into sea
- Br parliament imposed Intolerable act in 1774 taking away self-governance of Massachusetts
- Gov sent forces to enforce it
- 4th July 1776 in Philadelphia proclamation of Independence made
Role of Fr
- Fr provided military, fin support
- More than 5 mil Livre
- Fr commanders trained Am
- Loss of Canada for the French was big set-back they wanted to give it back to the Br for it
Conflict b/w Br Mercantilism and Am Capitalism
- Notion of Freedom strong w/ A
- Private property was imp part of society
- Spirit of Individualism
- Br Mercantilism was against all these
- Monopolistic trade practices, favourable balance of trade, accumulation of wealth against philosophy of capitalism
Impact of American Revolution
- L E F popularised
- 1st modern democracy
- Concept of Natural Rights of Men by John Locke
- 1789 gave FR to A citizens
- Inspired the Declaration of Right of France in 1791
- 1st Modern written constitution
- Inspired many trans-Atlantic revolutions
- Fr soldiers carried the ideas of AR to Fr eg Lafayette, Depleted Fr treasury
- Ireland in 1798
- Latin America
- Fuelled hostilities b/w Br, Fr
- Made British colonialism apprehensive of such revolution in India
- Inspired Nationalism in different country
- Started de-colonialization
- Am emerged as most progressive, liberal, began Am ascendency in Modern World
American Constitution :
- 1st written constitution
Factors Involved in Drafting of American Constitution
- Ideas of Enlightenment : L,E,F, Rule of Law, Separation of power
- Idea of Freedom, Private property etc that developed during their history
- Cultural O/C of American people was mixture of various social, religious and economic background of people
- Bitter experience of Br rule - checks and balances introduced to prevent despotic rule, Separation of powers
- Lost faith in the institution of Monarchy and popularisation of the ideas of Republicanism
- Idea of Capitalism
Features
- 1st written constitution
- Republican sys of govt
- Presidential
- Federal Polity
- Judicial Supremacy
- Dual Citizenship
- Ideas of Natural Rights of citizens
- Ideas of Laissez Fair
- Capitalistic Philosophy, Rule of Law,
Interpretation of Am Constitution :
- Charles A Beard 1913 : AC is an economic document designed by those with money and property to protect those with money and property. AC was the result of Marxian style class struggle.
- most Congress delegates rich merchants & big landlords
- who were selected on voters whose voting rights were based on the property qualification
- 3/4th of qualified voters were excluded during this, 25/55 delegates were slave owners
- coup of rich class most features like Right to property as a fundamental right, continuance of slavery, Laissez faire etc were all manifestation of aspirations of the rich section
- This ides of AC being an economic constitution is Challenged by Robert Brown and *Forest Macdonald.
- Idea of equal protection of law
- Guarantees freedom of religious beliefs
- Guarantees personal liberty
Unit-3.pdf American Revolution IGNOU BA
PYQ
11-10-2022 18:00
American Revolution
- "At the news of the Declaration of Independence crowds gathered to cheer, fire guns and cannon and ring church bells in Philadelphia. Boston and other places, but there were many people in America who did not rejoice." Comment. [1988, 20 Marks]
- Blacks and Native Americans suspicious of new regime, eastward expansion war w/ various clans, supporters still there
There were several groups of people in the American colonies who did not rejoice at the news of the Declaration of Independence.
1. Loyalists: These were American colonists who remained loyal to the British Crown. They saw the revolution as a rebellion against a legitimate government and feared the economic and social upheaval that a war for independence would bring.
2. Enslaved people: The Declaration of Independence did not include enslaved people as its signers believed that it would have been detrimental to the cause of independence. Enslaved people were not able to rejoice at the news of the Declaration of Independence as it did not bring them any immediate change in their status or guarantee them any rights.
3. Indigenous peoples: The Declaration of Independence did not include the rights and freedoms of indigenous peoples. The ongoing colonization of their lands and the treatment of them as "savages" by the colonizers meant that the Declaration of Independence did not bring them any hope of autonomy or self-government.
4. Women: The Declaration of Independence did not include women, as the signers believed that it would have been detrimental to the cause of independence. Women were not able to rejoice at the news of the Declaration of Independence as it did not bring them any immediate change in their rights and status.
- "The American War of Independence transformed Europeans as well as America." Comment. [1990, 2018, 20 Marks]
Europe
• Increased awareness of the potential for democratic government, as the American Revolution provided a model for other nations to emulate.
• The revolution had a profound impact on the European political landscape, as it inspired the French Revolution and other movements for independence throughout Europe.
• The war also had a significant economic impact, as the British government was forced to borrow heavily from the Dutch and other European nations to fund the war effort.
• The war also resulted in increased trade between the United States and Europe, as the newly independent nation began to build economic ties with its former colonial master.
• The war also helped to spread the ideals of the Enlightenment throughout Europe, as the American Revolution was seen as a victory for the principles of liberty and self-government.
America
• The American Revolution resulted in the creation of a new nation, the United States of America, and the adoption of a new constitution.
• The war also resulted in the end of British colonial rule in the United States, and the establishment of a new system of government based on the principles of democracy and self-determination.
• The war also resulted in the expansion of American territory, as the new nation acquired land from the British in the Treaty of Paris.
• The war also led to the establishment of a new economic system, as the United States began to develop an economy based on free trade and commerce.
• It also resulted in the development of a new national identity, as Americans began to identify themselves as citizens of a new nation.
- The American Revolution "was a natural and even expected event in the history of colonial people who had come of age." Comment. [1995, 20 Marks]
The American Revolution was a natural and expected event in the history of colonial people who had come of age because of a number of factors.
Firstly, the colonies had been growing and developing independently of British control for a significant period of time. The colonies had their own economies, culture and social structures, and the idea of being ruled by a distant government had become increasingly unacceptable. The British government's attempts to exert tighter control over the colonies, such as through the Quartering Acts and the Stamp Act, only served to further alienate the colonists.
Secondly, Enlightenment ideas were increasingly influencing the colonies, particularly the ideas of self-government and individual rights. The colonists had been exposed to these ideas through books, pamphlets and other forms of media, and they began to see themselves as being entitled to the same rights and freedoms as the British citizens. The slogan "No taxation without representation" encapsulated this sentiment, as the colonists were angry that they were being taxed by a government in which they had no representation.
Additionally, the colonies had been growing more self-sufficient over time, and the British government's attempts to exert control over trade and commerce were seen as unjust. The Navigation Acts and other trade regulations were viewed as an infringement of the colonists' right to make a living.
Furthermore, the colonies had already been experiencing a degree of self-rule. They had their own elected assemblies and local governments, and the idea of self-government was already a part of colonial society. The British government's attempts to exert more control over the colonies were seen as a violation of the colonists' rights to self-rule.
- The American War of Independence "deprived Great Britain of one empire, but it strengthened the foundations of another". Comment [1998, 20 Marks]
The American War of Independence, also known as the Revolutionary War, was a conflict between the 13 British colonies in North America and Great Britain that lasted from 1775 to 1783. The war resulted in the independence of the United States of America from British rule, and the establishment of a new nation. The war was a major turning point in world history, as it marked the beginning of the end of the colonial era and the rise of the modern nation-state.
The American War of Independence was a significant event in world history, as it marked the end of the British Empire in North America. The war resulted in the loss of a major source of wealth and power for Great Britain, as the colonies had been a major part of the British economy. The war also resulted in the loss of the British military presence in North America, as the British forces were forced to withdraw from the colonies. However, the war also had a positive impact on Great Britain, as it strengthened the foundations of another empire: the British Empire in India.
The British had established a presence in India in the early 1600s, and by the time of the American War of Independence, the British had become the dominant power in the region. The war provided the British with an opportunity to expand their influence in India, as the British forces in North America were withdrawn and redeployed to India. This allowed the British to consolidate their power in the region and to expand their trade networks. The British also used the war as an opportunity to modernize the Indian economy, introducing new technologies and modernizing the infrastructure.
The American War of Independence also had a positive impact on India in terms of social and political reforms. The war provided the British with an opportunity to implement reforms in India, such as the abolition of Sati in 1849 and the introduction of representative government later in the 20th century. The war also provided the British with an opportunity to expand their influence in the region, as they were able to take control of more territory in India.
- "No taxation without representation." Comment. [2006, 20 Marks]
"No taxation without representation" is a phrase that originated during the American Revolution and was used to express the colonists' frustration with being taxed by a government in which they had no representation. The phrase was used as a slogan to protest against British taxes, particularly the Stamp Act of 1765, which placed a tax on printed materials in the colonies.
The phrase was not coined by a single person, but it was a popular sentiment among the colonists, particularly in the years leading up to the American Revolution. It was used by many leaders of the revolution, including James Otis, who in a speech in 1761, said: "Taxation without representation is tyranny." It was also used by many political leaders, such as Samuel Adams, who used it as a rallying cry for the Sons of Liberty, a group of colonists who opposed British rule.
There were several major causes of concern for the colonists that made them protest against the British government leading up to the American Revolution. Some of the most significant causes of concern were:
1. Taxation: The colonists were particularly angry about the taxes that the British government imposed on them, such as the Stamp Act of 1765 and the Townshend Acts of 1767, which placed taxes on printed materials, glass, lead, paint, and tea. The colonists felt that they were being unjustly taxed by a government in which they had no representation.
2. Control over trade and commerce: The British government also attempted to exert control over trade and commerce in the colonies through the Navigation Acts and other trade regulations. The colonists viewed these regulations as an infringement of their right to make a living, and they felt that the British government was trying to strangle their economy.
3. Restrictions on civil liberties: The British government also placed restrictions on civil liberties in the colonies, such as through the Quartering Acts, which required colonists to provide quarters for British soldiers. The colonists felt that these restrictions were an infringement of their rights and freedoms.
4. Military presence: The British government maintained a significant military presence in the colonies, which the colonists saw as a threat to their security and a burden on their economy.
5. Idea of self governance: The colonies had been growing and developing independently of British control for a significant period of time, and the idea of being ruled by a distant government had become increasingly unacceptable. The colonists had their own elected assemblies and local governments, and the idea of self-government was already a part of colonial society. They believed that they were entitled to the same rights and freedoms as British citizens, and they felt that the British government was taking away their rights.
6. Enlightenment ideas: The colonists had been exposed to the ideas of the Enlightenment, such as the belief in natural rights and self-government, and they began to see themselves as being entitled to the same rights and freedoms as British citizens.
- "The American Revolution was essentially an economic conflict between American capitalism and British mercantilism." Critically examine. [2012, 10 Marks]
There are arguments that the American Revolution was essentially an economic conflict between American capitalism and British mercantilism. Here are five reasons why it may be seen as such:
1. Taxation: The British government imposed a number of taxes on the colonies, such as the Stamp Act and the Townshend Acts, which placed taxes on printed materials, glass, lead, paint, and tea. The colonists felt that these taxes were an infringement on their economic freedom and were a burden on their ability to conduct business.
2. Control over trade and commerce: The British government also attempted to exert control over trade and commerce in the colonies through the Navigation Acts and other trade regulations. These regulations were seen as an infringement on the colonists' ability to make a living and conduct business.
3. Mercantilism: The British government followed a policy of mercantilism, which sought to maintain a positive balance of trade and control the colonies' economies for the benefit of the mother country. The colonists felt that this policy was detrimental to their own economic interests.
4. American capitalism: The colonies had been developing their own capitalist economy, with a growing middle class and an entrepreneurial spirit. The colonists felt that the British government's attempts to control their economy were a threat to their economic freedom and prosperity.
5. Economic motives: Some of the colonists were motivated by economic grievances, such as wealthy merchants who stood to gain from breaking away from British regulations and taxes.
However, there are also reasons why the American Revolution may not be seen as solely an economic conflict:
1. Ideological causes: The colonists were also motivated by ideological causes, such as the belief in natural rights and self-government, which were influenced by Enlightenment ideas.
2. Political causes: The colonists were also motivated by political causes, such as a desire for representation in the British government and opposition to the British government's attempts to exert control over the colonies.
3. Social causes: The colonies had a strong sense of unity and shared identity, which was formed through shared experiences and a shared identity. This sense of unity and shared identity helped to unite the colonies and gave them a shared sense of purpose.
4. Military cause: The revolution was fought as a military conflict, with soldiers and generals leading the charge against the British army.
5. Not all colonies were motivated by economic reasons, as some were motivated by political or ideological reasons.
In conclusion, the American Revolution was a complex event with multiple causes, and it can be argued that economic causes played a significant role, but it was not the only cause. The British government's attempts to exert control over the colonies' economy, the colonists' belief in their own economic freedom, the growth of American capitalism, and the influence of mercantilism were all factors that contributed to the economic aspect of the conflict, but other factors such as ideological, political, social, and military causes also played a significant role.
Historian Charles Beard in his book "An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States" (1913) argues that the American Revolution was primarily driven by economic motives, particularly the desire of wealthy merchants and landowners to break free from British economic regulations and taxes.
Others historians argue that the revolution was driven by a combination of factors, including economic, political, ideological, and social causes. For example, historian Gordon S. Wood in his book "The Radicalism of the American Revolution" (1992) argues that the revolution was driven by a desire for political and social equality, and that economic grievances were secondary to these more fundamental causes.
- "American Revolution seems to have come with remarkable suddenness. A roster of talented leaders emerged during 1763 to 1775 to make it happen." Elucidate. [2014, 20 Marks]
- Townshend act 1767, onwards including immediate circumstances
The American Revolution has been called sudden for a number of reasons:
1. Speed of events: The events leading up to the revolution occurred relatively quickly, with the initial protests and resistance beginning in the 1760s and culminating in the Declaration of Independence in 1776.
2. Lack of precedent: There was no clear precedent for the colonies to break away from British rule, and the idea of revolution was relatively new and unexpected.
3. Emergence of leaders: A roster of talented leaders emerged during the years leading up to the revolution, who were able to organize and mobilize the colonists towards revolution.
4. Ideological causes: The ideas of the Enlightenment, such as the belief in natural rights and self-government, had a significant influence on the colonists and helped to spur the revolution.
5. Unification of colonies: The colonies had a strong sense of unity, which was formed through shared experiences and a shared identity. The idea of a united America was already taking shape, and the Declaration of Independence was the formalization of that idea.
As for the leaders, some of the key figures who emerged during 1763 to 1775 and made significant contributions to the revolution include:
1. Samuel Adams: He was a political leader who used the slogan "No taxation without representation" as a rallying cry for the Sons of Liberty, a group of colonists who opposed British rule.
2. John Adams: He was a lawyer and political leader who played a key role in drafting the Declaration of Independence.
3. Thomas Paine: He was an author and political leader who wrote the influential pamphlet "Common Sense," which argued for American independence.
4. Thomas Jefferson: He was a writer, lawyer and political leader who wrote the Declaration of Independence.
5. George Washington: He was a military leader who served as the commander-in-chief of the Continental Army during the American Revolution.
6. Benjamin Franklin: He was a polymath and one of the Founding Fathers of the United States who played a major role in the American Revolution.
- "The American War of Independence transformed Europe as well as America." Critically examine. [2018, 10 Marks]
- ! Mentioned above.
American Constitution
- What were the factors that worked in the drafting of the American Constitution? Do you agree with Beard's view of the Constitution being an Economic Document? [2005, 60 Marks]
1. The Articles of Confederation: The weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation, the first constitution of the United States, served as a catalyst for the drafting of a new constitution. Issues such as lack of central authority, inability to regulate trade and taxes, and the inability to raise an army, were some of the reasons that prompted the drafting of a new constitution.
2. Economic Interests: The drafting of the Constitution was heavily influenced by the economic interests of the framers. Many of the framers were wealthy landholders and merchants who sought to protect their property and commercial interests through the Constitution.
3. Political Philosophy: The framers of the Constitution were heavily influenced by Enlightenment philosophy, particularly the ideas of John Locke and Montesquieu. These ideas, such as the separation of powers and the idea of limited government, are reflected in the Constitution.
4. The Federalist Papers: The Federalist Papers, written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay, were influential in the drafting of the Constitution. They were a series of essays that argued for the ratification of the Constitution, and helped to persuade the states to approve the new Constitution.
5. Compromise: Compromise played a crucial role in the drafting of the Constitution. The framers had to compromise on issues such as representation in Congress, slavery, and the power of the federal government. This helped to create a document that was acceptable to the majority of the framers.
Charles A. Beard, an American historian, in his book "An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States" argued that the Constitution was primarily an economic document that protected the economic interests of the wealthy framers. He believed that the framers had primarily economic interests and that the Constitution was written to protect their property and commercial interests.
Reasons in support of Beard's view:
- Many of the framers of the Constitution were wealthy landholders and merchants who sought to protect their property and commercial interests through the Constitution.
- The Constitution includes provisions such as the Commerce Clause, which gives the federal government the power to regulate trade, and the Contract Clause, which protects the rights of creditors, which support this view.
Reasons against Beard's view:
- The Constitution also includes provisions such as the Bill of Rights, which protect individual rights, and the Separation of Powers, which limits government power, which do not support Beard's view that the Constitution is only an economic document.
- Other historians argue that the framers had a more broad-minded and idealistic view of the Constitution, and that they believed in creating a government that would protect the rights and interests of all citizens, not just the wealthy.
Overall, while it is true that the economic interests of the framers did play a role in the drafting of the Constitution, it is not accurate to say that the Constitution was solely an economic document. The Constitution was the result of a complex series of compromises and negotiation and reflected a diverse set of interests, ideas and beliefs.
- How far is it correct to say that every feature of the American Constitution was ultimately of English Origin? [2010, 20 Marks]
- Interpretation of Am Constitution : more content needed
- Features
It is not entirely accurate to say that every feature of the American Constitution was ultimately of English origin. While the American Constitution was heavily influenced by English political thought and practice, there were also significant indigenous or original features that were developed by the framers.
Features of English origin:
1. The concept of separation of powers: The idea of separating the powers of government into different branches (legislative, executive, and judicial) was heavily influenced by the work of English political philosopher John Locke.
2. The common law system: The American legal system is based on the English common law system, which is a system of laws based on tradition and court decisions rather than statutes.
3. The concept of bicameralism: The American Congress is composed of two chambers (the Senate and the House of Representatives) which is modeled on the bicameral system of the British Parliament.
4. The Bill of Rights: The first ten amendments to the Constitution, known as the Bill of Rights, were heavily influenced by the English Bill of Rights of 1689.
5. The concept of federalism: The division of power between the national government and state governments, known as federalism, is based on the British system of government.
6. The presidential system: The American presidential system, where the president is both the head of state and head of government, was modeled on the British system, where the monarch serves as the head of state.
7. The idea of a written Constitution: The idea of a written Constitution, which lays out the fundamental principles of government, was borrowed from the English political tradition.
Features of Indigenous origin:
1. The principle of popular sovereignty: The idea that the ultimate authority in government resides in the people, as opposed to a monarch or other ruler, is an indigenous feature of the American Constitution.
2. The principle of representation: The Constitution provides for the direct election of members of the House of Representatives, which is an indigenous feature and not a practice in the British system.
3. The principle of checks and balances: The system of checks and balances, which limits the power of each branch of government, is an indigenous feature of the Constitution.
4. The principle of judicial review: The power of the Supreme Court to review the constitutionality of laws and government actions is an indigenous feature of the Constitution.
5. The principle of republicanism: The American Constitution established a republican form of government, in which citizens elect representatives to govern on their behalf, which is distinct from the British system where the monarch is the head of state.
It is important to note that the American Constitution was not just a copy of the British system, but it was a unique document that reflected the ideas, political traditions and experiences of the framers. It was a result of a complex series of compromise and negotiation and reflected a diverse set of interests, ideas and beliefs.
- Explain the main features of the US Federal Constitution. [2016, 10 Marks]
- [Features](onenote: American %20Revolution%20and%20the%20Constitution§ion-id={BAF25296-16C1-46BC-85CA-B17A471F7C04}&page-id={672EEAC5-5669-4D3A-BD58-2E35824B3C11}&object-id={D6209584-A7DD-42BA-809D-37B79FB9B185}&48&base-path= https://d.docs.live.net/bbc8be5bd337910c/Documents/History%20Optional/World%20History/Part%20I/Modern%20Politics%20-%20Origin.one )
The United States Constitution is the supreme law of the United States and the foundation of the federal government. It was adopted in 1787 and has since served as the model for many other constitutions around the world. The main features of the U.S. Federal Constitution are:
1. Separation of powers: The Constitution establishes a system of separation of powers among the legislative, executive and judicial branches of government. This ensures that no one branch of government becomes too powerful and allows for checks and balances among the branches.
2. Federalism: The Constitution establishes a federal system of government, in which power is divided between the national government and the state governments. This allows for a balance of power between the national and state governments and ensures that the states have a degree of autonomy.
3. Limited government: The Constitution limits the powers of the federal government, outlining specific powers that the government is allowed to exercise, such as the power to regulate commerce and to declare war.
4. Bill of Rights: The Constitution includes the first 10 amendments, known as the Bill of Rights, which protect individual rights such as freedom of speech, religion and the press, the right to bear arms, and the right to a fair trial.
5. Representation: The Constitution establishes a representative democracy, in which citizens elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf. It also establishes the electoral college for the selection of the President.
6. Checks and Balances: The Constitution provides a system of checks and balances among the branches of government, so that no branch becomes too powerful. This ensures that the government remains accountable to the people and that the rights of citizens are protected.
7. Supremacy Clause: The Constitution establishes the principle of federal supremacy, which means that the federal government's laws and Constitution are the supreme law of the land.
8. Amendments: The Constitution provides a way for the Constitution to be amended, which means that the Constitution can adapt to the changing needs of the country over time.
9. Preamble: A Preamble is a statement of the Constitution's purpose, which sets out the goals and objectives of the government and the country as a whole.
10. Eligibility criteria: The Constitution establishes the eligibility criteria for holding certain federal offices, such as being at least 35 years of age to be President and being a natural-born citizen of the United States.
11. Impeachment: The Constitution establishes the process of impeachment, which allows for the removal of federal officials from office for committing "high crimes and misdemeanors."
12. Presidential veto: The Constitution grants the President the power to veto legislation passed by Congress, allowing the President to have a role in the legislative process.
13. Commerce Clause: The Constitution grants Congress the power to regulate commerce among the states, allowing for the regulation of trade and economic activity among the states.
14. Necessary and Proper Clause: The Constitution grants Congress the power to pass any laws "necessary and proper" for carrying out its other powers and duties.
These are some of the main features of the U.S Federal Constitution, which establish the framework and principles of the federal government and protect individual rights and freedoms. The Constitution serves as the foundation of the American political system, and its principles continue to shape the country's political, economic and social landscape.