11.14 Alberuni

Alberuni

2020-04-27 12:05:17


  • Alberuni 972-1048, Muslim indologist, polymath, first anthropologist, Tarikh Ul Hind, founder of Indology
  • 1017 came to India, studied religion, language, philosophy
  • Ghazni patronised him along w/ many other scholar like Firdausi
  • Helped modern Historians identify initial year of Gupta era it began 241 yrs before Shaka

Khitab Ul Hind Aka Tarikh Ul Hind -

  • Accounts the socio-religious condition, institutions
  • Shortcomings of their socio-political order that led to defeat
  • Philosophy, religion, alchemy, social life, laws, science etc
  • Chapters begin with question, concludes w/ comparison to other cultures
  • Narrates political history chronologically
  • IN depended on tradition heavily, criticises social discrimination prevalent, lack scientific spirit, arrogance of Brahmans cause of it
  • Learnt Sanskrit to study Indian texts, quoted Gita, Puranas, Patanjali etc
  • Also analysed oral sources, advices historians to be critical
  • Records facts, admits his shortcomings, presents his views without bias
  • Hindus don't write on hides In the south on tari leaves/ leaves of date palm and In North and Central India on the bark of tuz tree
  • Acknowledges the existence of various scripts

Religion

  • Hinduism Islam totally different, M attacks made H suspicious of all foreigners, considered M as barbarians
  • Compares Indian philosophy to Greek

Society

  • Caste ridden, do not live together at same place, not allowed to dine together.
  • Antyaja were below Shudras included juggler, shoemakers, sailors, weaver etc lived outside city.
  • Untouchables also mentioned like Chandalas.
  • Only Brahmans Kshatriyas capable of attaining Moksha
  • Compares it with social division of ancient Persia.
  • Vaishyas were degenerating to rank of Shudras.
  • Forbidden to go overseas, do not like sharing their knowledge
  • Social evils child marriage, sati, low position of women esp widows.
  • Mentions rich heritage of India.
  • Cutoms like earthern plates, chewing arecanut, turbans in vogue, permission while leaving from women.

Religion

  • Mentions festivals, educated H believed in one eternal god, w/o beginning or end
  • Calls polytheism as vulgar, mentions beliefs in spirits, souls not differing from each other
  • Concept of Naraka, Swarg, Moksha
  • transmigration of soul, karma defining their next birth

Polity

  • Dates destruction of Somnath by Mahmud, not gives infor about political events
  • History of Hindushahi's

Science

  • IN had knowledge of astronomy, metrology, alchemy, geography, mathematics
  • Critical account, Astronomy most popular connected w/ religion, mentions Varahmihira's Panchasiddhantika, Brahmagupta, Arayabhatta Dasagitika
  • Planets and their motion, zodiac signs
  • Causes for solar, lunar eclipse known
  • Calculation of equinoxes, earth rotated around sun elliptical in shape
  • Tola, Yava, Kala, Dropa are some measures of weight
  • Arithmetic - Brahmagupta
  • Charaka Samhita known,
  • Decimal system, zero were know, mentions value of pi
  • Considers his knowledge superior to others, compares alchemy to witchcraft
  • Hindus are haughty, foolish, superiority complex

Criticism of Alberuni

  • Depended only on Brahmana works
  • Misinterpretation wrong understanding of texts
  • Ignored non Sanskrit text
  • Does not mentions places he visited, lacks positive evidence, myths are taken as facts
  • Direct observational description is lacking
  • Oral informants could be wrong

PYQs and Answers

  1. Discuss the salient features of Indian society on the eve of the campaigns of Mahmud of Ghazni, with particular reference to the observations made by Al-Biruni. [1989, 60m]

- ! Society Portion mentioned in Notes aboce

  1. Write a short essay on: "AIBiruni's India" [1998, 20m]

Al-Biruni was a Persian scholar who accompanied Mahmud of Ghazni on his campaigns to India in the 11th century CE. He wrote a book called Kitab-ul-Hind or Tahqiq-i-Hind (The Book of India or The Verification of India) which is considered one of the most comprehensive and objective accounts of Indian society, culture, religion, science and history at that time.

Some of the salient features of Indian society on the eve of Mahmud Ghazni’s campaigns, as observed by Al-Biruni, are:

Indian society was divided into four varnas or castes (Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and Shudras) based on birth and occupation. The caste system was rigid and hierarchical, with Brahmins enjoying the highest status and privileges, while Shudras were treated as untouchables and oppressed. There were also many sub-castes within each varna12.
Indian society was also divided into different religious sects such as Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, Ajivikas etc. Each sect had its own scriptures, rituals, customs and beliefs. Al-Biruni studied various Hindu scriptures such as Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas etc. and tried to understand their philosophy and cosmology. He also compared Hinduism with other religions such as Islam, Christianity and Zoroastrianism132.
Indian society was rich in culture and learning. Al-Biruni admired the achievements of Indians in fields such as mathematics, astronomy, medicine, grammar etc. He learned Sanskrit language and translated some works from Sanskrit to Arabic. He also appreciated the art, architecture, music and poetry of Indians.

Indian society was also marked by some drawbacks such as superstitions, idolatry, polytheism etc. Al-Biruni criticized some aspects of Hindu religion such as animal sacrifices, cremation rites etc. He also noted some social evils such as child marriage, sati (widow immolation), untouchability etc.

  1. Attempt a critical essay of the Indian Science and Civilization in the light of Alberuni's writings. What merits and drawbacks, do you find in his account? [2003, 60m]
  1. Evaluate the 'Kitab al-Hind' of Alberuni as a source of history of India. [2014, 15m]
  1. Comment on the veracity of Alberuni's account of the Indian society. [2016, 10 Marks]
  1. Write a short essay on: "Alberuni on science in India" [2007, 20m]